All three top-flight goals notched by the forward this season have come away from home.
At a glance
Nottingham Forest climb above Spurs into 16th, a three-point cushion above the drop zone.
Igor Jesus heads his side ahead just before half-time.
The England midfielder scores a second and substitute Taiwo Awoniyi seals the victory.
Tottenham sit only one point clear of the bottom three and are yet to win in the league this calendar year.
The visitors secured a massive step towards survival and plunged Tottenham further into the drop fight with a devastating win in North London.
The Forest striker, their playmaker and Taiwo Awoniyi settled the basement battle to lift Forest a valuable margin clear of the Premier League's drop zone.
The Tricky Trees overtook their opponents into 16th, leaving the hosts a point clear of the bottom three after other results.
This result throws renewed uncertainty over the position of Tottenham interim manager Igor Tudor, who has been at the helm for a brief spell.
Tottenham failed to sign the midfielder last summer, a transfer saga which left Forest threatening Spurs with a formal complaint.
Fast forward seven-and-a-half months, the England midfielder's goal may have served to edge them nearer the Championship in a pivotal outcome for Nottingham Forest – the maiden victory in the Premier League for manager Vitor Pereira since his arrival in February.
Spurs are now without a win in the top flight since late December, have lost six of their past seven matches and are falling apart during Tudor's tenure.
The Croatian has suffered defeat in five of his seven matches at the helm and Sunday's result may prove the most damaging of all.
Tottenham were on top in the first half but the Forest forward – who had earlier deflected the ball onto his own crossbar – nodded in the first goal in first-half stoppage time.
Mathys Tel struck the woodwork before the break as Spurs searched for an instant response but fell further behind after 62 minutes when the midfielder was left unmarked in the area and his effort from a teammate's cutback went through Guglielmo Vicario's hands.
Once Spurs substitute the Swedish midfielder sliced a good chance wide, a comeback looked unlikely and the substitute added a third with a few minutes left, leaving Tottenham with a handful of fixtures to preserve their Premier League future.
Spurs Breakdown: Manager Under Fire with Tottenham Cheered On and Booed Off
What is the path forward for Tottenham go from here?
It was incredibly damaging if they had tried and a sixth defeat in seven Premier League games pushes them closer to relegation.
The manager's job must now be in doubt just over a month after being appointed as the previous manager's successor.
Tudor has earned just a point from his five league matches and suffered a heavy defeat against Forest – who had not won in the top division for two months.
Spurs are in turmoil and could suffer dropping from the Premier League for the first time since 1977.
It was almost predictable. Spurs began with some purpose amid support from the supporters but that evaporated in the latter period.
Igor Jesus' goal quietened the home ground and Gibbs-White's goal was the signal for a section of supporters to head for the exits.
Awoniyi added more pain but after only two home league wins this term – against two other sides – it should not come as a surprise.
Tottenham were cheered on and jeered at the end and their Premier League fate is increasingly hanging by a thread.
Nottingham Forest Analysis: Pereira's First Premier League Win for 11 Months Proves Vital for Forest
Pereira was without a win in the Premier League since last April.
He left Wolves in November winless this season and it has taken five attempts to secure three top-flight points at Forest but they will be massive for their campaign.
Narrow losses against strong opposition were creditable while a draw at Manchester City showed the squad's quality and grit.
It was Forest's second three-goal victory against Spurs in the league this season, their first coming under their former manager in December, and it was equally merited.
At Tottenham, they weathered the early pressure in the opening phase and seldom appeared in trouble after the first goal.
The goalscorer has scored just three goals in the league this season since a multi-million pound transfer from Botafogo last summer.
All of them have earned Forest points, with a 1-0 win at Molineux and a win at Brentford. His latest goal was his thirteenth strike of the campaign, with a number arriving in the European competition.
But none may prove as crucial as this one as Forest gain confidence after their midweek penalty shootout win which earned a Europa League quarter-final with the Portuguese giants.
Now there is a rock solid belief they will stay up from here, with West Ham and Tottenham potentially left to fight it out for survival.
What's Next for Both Sides?
Tottenham visit the Stadium of Light in the league on April 12th while Forest journey to Porto for their Europa League quarter-final first leg on 9 April before they welcome Villa in the Premier League on the same weekend.